Muldoon’s on Main

111 W Main St Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032, USA

About Muldoon’s on Main

4.5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Sarah Barnett
    May 25, 2024

    Ventured up to Muldoon’s on Main after seeing a recommendation to try the tenderloin. Overall it was just ok but not the best tenderloin by far. We went on a weekday around 1 and it was pretty empty. Street parking was easy to find than I thought it would be. We ordered the fried cheese as an app. I ordered the mini tenderloin and sweet potato fries while my bf got the regular tenderloin and onion rings. The fried cheese was probably my favorite part of the meal but I didn’t care for the mayo/dijon dip it came with, would have preferred a ranch or choice of different aioli’s. Unfortunately our meals came out as I took the first bite of our app which really kinda ruins an app in my opinion. It is a large app, I’d say perfect for four people but too much for just two people. The mini tenderloin seemed pretty much that same size as my bf’s regular but his came with a sesame bun. Usually when I get a mini or small tenderloin at restaurants it is usually bun size but a little thicker but this on still was quite large with at least half hanging over. The tenderloin itself was juicy but the breading was a little salty for my preference. Sweet potato fries were good but a little under cooked, also wished they offered some type of dip for them like a Carmel or marshmallow fluff. The breading between the fried cheese, tenderloins, and onion rings all seemed very similar and the saltiness over powered some of the other flavors. Service was lacking, even though they weren’t busy. The waitress did check on us once during the meal but didn’t offer to refill our empty drinks at all. I think the pricing was off too. I mean I guess I should expect it from a Carmel location but 70 something after tip still seems high for some fried food at an Irish pub for lunch.

    Rhonda Spurgeon
    April 04, 2024

    The tenderloin was very good, and the right thickness! The onion rings were massive and delicious! The banana cream pie was good but, it didn't have enough bananas, I enjoyed it anyway! Our waitress, Shannon was very attentive and friendly! I recommend Muldoons for a good meal!

    Joey Chen
    April 30, 2024

    Great little location, saw many rave reviews on their pork tenderloin sandwich and it definitely did not disappoint. The service was good and the food was very tasty, would come here again.

    Rick Roseberry
    September 12, 2023

    An excellent dining experience. Fast friendly service and tasty food. As an appetizer we got the fried cheese (and adult take on mozzarella sticks) and I got the Breaded Pork Tenderloin and my wife got the French Dip. The appetizer and sandwiches delicious. I got a Black and Tan and it was tasty as well. We would not hesitate to go back if the opportunity presents itself.

    Heino Puidak
    August 14, 2023

    The Pork Tenderloin Is Spectacular! We were in the area for a wedding and knew that Indiana was famous for pork tenderloin sandwiches so we did some searches and went to Muldoon's. We went for lunch and had a nice seat out on the covered patio. Just as their menu says, their pork t-loin sandwiches are award winners so we had to try. My wife had the Mini Breaded tenderloin sandwich ($11.99) with an included side of Kettle potato chips. I had to try the full size Breaded Tenderloin sandwich ($13.99) with included side of french fries. Our orders came to the table and they looked great. The Mini t-loin still hung over the bun by inches and my full sizer was more than double the bun size! I cut it in half and double stacked it. Lettuce, tomato, mayo and sliced pickles accompanied the sandwich. I had them bring me some raw onion. The breading was light and crunchy, the pork had a great pork flavor and was very moist. Now we know why their pork t-loin is award winning. The french fries were tasty also. Twice fried and seasoned with a crunchy exterior, soft interior. You've got to try this place!

    Muldoon’s on Main

    Our Address

    111 W Main St Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032, USA

    See Your Venue Listed Here!

    Want to Be Featured In This Directory? For more information on our listings, advertising, and how to increase your venue attendance, please contact us today!