Chatham Tap Butler

4702 Sunset Ave Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46208, USA

About Chatham Tap Butler

4.3 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Diane Ellis
    May 25, 2024

    Dropped in here for a drink and a bite to eat. We shared a pork tenderloin sandwich with an egg on it. It was delicious, but in hindsight, the egg didn't add much. A deep fried pork tenderloin doesn't benefit from the richness of an egg. We sat outside and it was very comfortable. It was graduation day so several families were there enjoying the day.

    May 05, 2024

    Update 05/05/24: We've been ordering from Chatham Tap Butler for the past six months and have loved their food. I finally stopped in for lunch yesterday. Great atmosphere and service. The Portabella Mushroom Fries were incredible and the Reuben was great. The Boneless Buffalo Chicken Wings were very tasty as well. We were looking for a new pizza to try and came across Chatham Tap (Uber Eats). We've had it twice. Overall, it's outstanding!! Our first pizza was so awesome, we decided to have the same one again... Thin crust, Gorgonzola, Asiago, Pepperoni, Mushroom, Red Onion, Bacon and Pesto Spread. Wow! What a combination! Unfortunately, our second order of the same was wrong... No Bacon, No Pesto Spread and it had ham on it (not for me, thanks). It was still good, but not what we ordered. Uber Eats refunded me for the missing toppings and we will order from them again, so all's good.

    Rachel Phillips
    April 11, 2024

    Leigh and Emma are the best servers/bartenders here! Karina makes the best food. You gotta try the pizzas! The drinks are fun and reasonably priced, and the location is awesome.

    Judah Telesford
    June 02, 2024

    The customer service and atmosphere was wonderful. The gentleman with the clean shaved head and glasses runs a tight ship as a manager. Our server Kay showed great customer care. Loved the spaciousness of the location. *Thumbs up*

    Marianne Sanada
    January 10, 2023

    Came here on a busy night before a show but didn't take too long to get seated although a ton of people showed up right after us. Server was very very nice but clearly pretty busy. But no complaints on service. Everyone was friendly! Fish and chips is a pass. When we got it it was not crunchy (soggy) but the fries were good! Fried pickles were ok, the sauce on the side is nice with a little spice. Tenderloin sandwich was just ok, not a ton of flavor and since we got it breaded it was just too much bread. Our friends liked their soft pretzels (especially the cinnamon sugar dip). And the buffalo dip was pretty good as well. This is a solid space before a show as it's super convenient and beer prices are pretty good as well. Likely to come back but will not get fish n chips or tenderloin sandwich. I'd say the food over all was a 3 but service was great so rounded up. I'd give it another try with different food items ☺️

    Chatham Tap Butler

    Our Address

    4702 Sunset Ave Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46208, USA

    See Your Venue Listed Here!

    Want to Be Featured In This Directory? For more information on our listings, advertising, and how to increase your venue attendance, please contact us today!